Game Mag Ratings

Game Mag Ratings › Best games

The 99 best Windows PC games

Ranked by the scores that magazines gave these games when they came out. The list draws on 9,180 review scores of 5,110 Windows PC games; 3,571 of them have enough reviews to be ranked.

#GamePlatformYearScore
1Portal 2Windows201199.2
2Half-Life 2Windows200497.3
3Grand Theft Auto VWindows201596
4Persona 5 RoyalWindows202295
5The Elder Scrolls V: SkyrimWindows201194.2
6BioShock InfiniteWindows201394
7Civilization IIWindows199694
8Civilization IVWindows200594
9Grand Theft Auto: Vice CityWindows200394
10Mass Effect 2Windows201094
11QuakeWindows199794
12The Elder Scrolls IV: OblivionWindows200694
13Half-LifeWindows199893.4
14Warcraft III: Reign of ChaosWindows200293.3
15BioShockWindows200793.2
16Company of HeroesWindows200693
17Divinity: Original Sin IIWindows201793
18Grand Theft Auto IIIWindows200293
19Grand Theft Auto: San AndreasWindows200593
20HadesWindows201893
21MinecraftWindows201193
22Red Dead Redemption IIWindows201993
23StarCraft II: Wings of LibertyWindows201093
24Tetris Effect: ConnectedWindows202193
25The Witcher III: Wild HuntWindows201593
26Unreal Tournament 2004Windows200493
27World of WarcraftWindows200493
28Deus ExWindows200092.7
29Call of DutyWindows200392
30Call of Duty 4: Modern WarfareWindows200792
31Galactic Civilizations II: Twilight of the ArnorWindows200892
32Pro Evolution Soccer 3Windows200392
33Sid Meier's GettysburgWindows199792
34Splinter Cell: Chaos TheoryWindows200592
35Team Fortress 2Windows200792
36UndertaleWindows201592
37StarCraftWindows199891.7
38Grim FandangoWindows199891.4
39Quake III: ArenaWindows199991.2
40Rome: Total WarWindows200491.1
41Batman: Arkham AsylumWindows200991
42Batman: Arkham CityWindows201191
43Battlefield 2Windows200591
44CrysisWindows200791
45Dark Souls IIWindows201491
46Disco ElysiumWindows201991
47DishonoredWindows201291
48F1 Challenge '99-'02Windows200391
49Fallout 3Windows200891
50FEZWindows201391
51Galactic Civilizations II: Dark AvatarWindows200791
52IL-2 SturmovikWindows200191
53Madden NFL 2004Windows200391
54Mark of the NinjaWindows201291
55Medal of Honor: Allied AssaultWindows200291
56Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom PainWindows201591
57Myth: The Fallen LordsWindows199791
58Neverwinter NightsWindows200291
59No One Lives Forever 2: A Spy In H.A.R.M.'s WayWindows200291
60OverwatchWindows201691
61Quake IIWindows199791
62Splinter CellWindows200391
63Street Fighter IVWindows200991
64The Longest JourneyWindows199991
65World of Warcraft: The Burning CrusadeWindows200791
66World of Warcraft: Wrath of the Lich KingWindows200891
67HomeworldWindows199990.9
68The Sims 2Windows200490.8
69Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2Windows200090.3
70System Shock 2Windows199990.3
71Knights of the Old RepublicWindows200390.1
72Black & WhiteWindows200190.1
73BayonettaWindows201790
74BraidWindows200990
75Brothers: A Tale of Two SonsWindows201390
76Civilization IIIWindows200190
77Civilization VWindows201090
78Command & Conquer: Red AlertWindows199690
79Dawn of WarWindows200490
80Deus Ex: Human RevolutionWindows201190
81Dota 2Windows201390
82Empire: Total WarWindows200990
83Falcon 4.0: Allied ForceWindows200590
84Flight Simulator 2002Windows200190
85Freedom ForceWindows200290
86Grand Theft Auto IVWindows200890
87GTR 2 – FIA GT Racing GameWindows200690
88Guild Wars 2Windows201290
89Half-Life 2: Episode TwoWindows200790
90Into The BreachWindows201890
91NHL 2001Windows200090
92PortalWindows200790
93Return to Castle WolfensteinWindows200190
94Silent Hunter IIIWindows200590
95Stephen's Sausage RollWindows201690
96Tetris EffectWindows201890
97Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3Windows200290
98Total War: Shogun 2Windows201190
99World of GooWindows200890

Highly rated, with fewer than 3 reviews

40 Windows PC games have a score of 90 or more, but from only one or two reviews, and no Metacritic score.

How the ranking works

The lists are rebuilt each time reviews are added. To filter by genre, year, magazine or publisher, explore all the scores in the report.

More lists

Best PC (MS-DOS and Windows) games MS-DOS Windows 3.1 All the lists