Game Mag Ratings

Game Mag Ratings › Best games

The 60 best 8th generation console games

All systems together, ranked by the scores that magazines gave these games when they came out. Systems: Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 4, Xbox One, Wii U. The list draws on 6,757 review scores of 4,323 games.

#GamePlatformYearScore
1The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the WildSwitch, Wii U2017100
2Red Dead Redemption IIXbox One, PS4201898
3Grand Theft Auto VXbox One, PS4201497
4Super Mario OdysseySwitch201796.4
5The House in Fata Morgana - Dreams of the Revenants Edition -Switch202196
6The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the KingdomSwitch202396
7Animal Crossing: New HorizonsSwitch202095
8Bayonetta 2Wii U, Switch201495
9God of WarPS4201895
10Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom PainXbox One, PS4201595
11Persona 5 RoyalPS4, Switch201995
12Portal: Companion CollectionSwitch202295
13The Last of Us – RemasteredPS4201495
14CelesteXbox One, Switch, PS4201894
15Metroid Prime RemasteredSwitch202394
16Tetris Effect: ConnectedSwitch202194
17Divinity: Original Sin IIXbox One, PS4201793
18Divinity: Original Sin II - Definitive EditionSwitch201993
19HadesSwitch202093
20INSIDEXbox One, PS4, Switch201693
21Ori and the Will of the WispsSwitch202093
22Persona 5PS4201693
23RESIDENT EVIL 2Xbox One201993
24Super Smash Bros. UltimateSwitch201893
25The Last of Us Part IIPS4202093
26UndertaleSwitch, PS4201893
27Forza Horizon 4Xbox One201892
28JourneyPS4201592
29Super Mario Bros. WonderSwitch202392
30Super Smash Bros. for Wii UWii U201492
31The Witcher 3: Wild HuntPS4, Xbox One201592
32What Remains of Edith FinchXbox One201792
33Super Mario 3D WorldWii U201391.4
34Dead CellsXbox One201891
35Dragon Quest XI SSwitch201991
36Dragon Quest XI S: Echoes of an Elusive Age - Definitive EditionPS4202091
37FlowerPS4201391
38Forza Horizon 3Xbox One201691
39OverwatchXbox One, PS4201691
40Resident Evil 2 RemakePS4201991
41Sekiro: Shadows Die TwiceXbox One, PS4201991
42Shadow of the ColossusPS4201891
43Shovel Knight: Treasure TroveSwitch201791
44Sonic Mania PlusSwitch201891
45SteamWorld HeistSwitch201791
46UnavowedSwitch202191
47Odin Sphere LeifthrasirPS4201690.8
48The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker HDWii U201390.5
49Donkey Kong Country: Tropical FreezeWii U201490.2
50New Super Mario Bros. UWii U201290.2
51Rayman LegendsWii U, PS4201390.2
52TitanfallXbox One201490.2
53BastionSwitch201890
54FEZPS4201490
55Guacamelee!: Super Turbo Championship EditionWii U201490
56Into The BreachSwitch201890
57Monster Hunter: WorldPS4, Xbox One201890
58NBA 2K17Xbox One201690
59Ori and the Blind Forest: Definitive EditionSwitch201990
60Shovel KnightPS4201590

Highly rated, with fewer than 3 reviews

52 titles have a score of 90 or more, but from only one or two reviews, and no Metacritic score.

#GamePlatformYearScore
Dragon Quest XIPS42017100
MinecraftPS4201497
Ryu ga Gotoku Ishin!PS4201497
BalatroSwitch202495
Bayonetta 3Switch202295
Ghost Trick: Phantom DetectivePS4202395
Jikkyou Powerful Pro Baseball 2018PS495
Rayman LegendsXbox One201495
SteamWorld DigPS4201495
Volgarr the VikingXbox One201495
ThreesXbox One201493
Jikkyou Powerful Pro Baseball 2016PS492
World Soccer Winning Eleven 2015Xbox One201492
LEGO Marvel Super HeroesXbox One201390
13 Sentinels: Aegis RimSwitch202290
AI: THE SOMNIUM FILES - nirvanA InitiativeSwitch202290
Aeon DriveSwitch202190
AnodyneSwitch201990
Atelier Sophie 2: The Alchemist of the Mysterious DreamPS4202290
Bahnsen KnightsSwitch202490
Beast BreakerSwitch202190
Beyond GalaxylandSwitch202490
Blue Reflection: Second LightSwitch202190
Border BreakPS4201890
Braid, Anniversary EditionSwitch202490
COCOONSwitch202390
Dot ArcadeWii U201590
Dragon Quest Heroes I-IISwitch201790
Fire Emblem EngageSwitch202390
Horizon Forbidden WestPS4202290
Hypnospace OutlawSwitch202090
Inertial DriftSwitch202090
Live A LiveSwitch202290
Mario + Rabbids: Sparks of HopeSwitch202290
NBA 2K14PS4201390
Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl 2Switch202390
Nobunaga's Ambition: Sphere of InfluenceSwitch201790
Nova-111Wii U201590
Okami HDXbox One201790
Peggle 2PS4201490
Pikmin 4Switch202390
Return to Monkey IslandSwitch202290
RoninPS4201690
STARWHALWii U201590
Shantae: Risky's Revenge - Director's CutWii U201690
Sound ShapesPS4201490
Sunset OverdriveXbox One201490
The BridgeXbox One201590
The SwapperWii U201490
Thomas Was AloneWii U201490
TumblestoneWii U201690
Unicorn OverlordSwitch202490

How the ranking works

The lists are rebuilt each time reviews are added. To filter by genre, year, magazine or publisher, explore all the scores in the report.

More lists

Best 2nd generation console games Best 3rd generation (8-bit) console games Best 4th generation (16-bit) console games Best 5th generation (32/64-bit) console games Best 6th generation console games Best 7th generation console games Best 9th generation console games Best 4th generation handheld games Best 5th generation handheld games Best 6th generation handheld games Best 7th generation handheld games Best 8th generation handheld games Best 8-bit home computer games Best 16/32-bit home computer games Best PC (MS-DOS and Windows) games All the lists